Today I read an article Forging Path to Starting Line for Younger Disabled Athletes by Mary Pilon on the New York Times that
talked about disabled athletes trying to beat sports officials in the topic of
whether they could compete with able bodied athletes. There are many challenges
for these athletes, especially ones in school (which seems to be the focus
of this article) when it comes to competition such as accommodations, safety,
and also, the fairness of specific things (ex. wheelchair vs. average human
runner). For example, Ariz Mesa, a tennis player deaf since birth, felt
discrimination against her when her interpreter who told her the scores was
taken away, resulting in the loss of a tournament during her sophomore year. Though
some states have already ensured that disabled students are included in sports
and extracurricular activities, some sports officials still seem to be
conflicted and unsure. With regards to safety and accommodation, many coaches
have already begun to explore this new idea of accommodating and including
disabled students in different areas of sports (even contact sports) and though
this struggle has only just begun, the first steps have at least been taken.
Seeing that the author has used many ways to show the sides and struggles of disabled athletes, I would say that she is definitely trying to get people to understand why they (disabled people) too should be included in the sports that we can do with ease. There is one specific quote that she used that I think shows her point very clearly and it is said by a 17 year old girl who uses a wheelchair when people told her that she, using a wheelchair, had an advantage. She said "I just didn't get the fact that they [sports officials] were saying I had an advantage because I was in a wheelchair. How do I have an advantage because I can't use half of my body? It didn't make any sense to me". This quote showed the athlete's anger (and perhaps the anger of the author as well) that Pilon may have wanted the readers to feel. Overall I would believe that Pilon wanted the readers to think about the unfair and harsh circumstances that disabled athletes must face. Not only was playing the sport already more difficult than it would be for able bodied people but getting to play it is harder for them as well and that point is what the author, Mary Pilon, wanted the readers to think about.
After reading this article I felt a deeper understanding of the struggles that disabled people have to face. It is horrible that people discriminate against them while at other times, treat them like they have too many advantages to be equal. There is no advantage to being disabled and it should be painfully obvious how hard life is for them already so why can't people take the step to make it easier for them? I very much agree with the author for even with their disabilities, disabled people are the same as us and deserve the same privileges as we do. If sport is something we enjoy (and it is) then they should be able to enjoy it too.
What are your opinions? Please feel free to comment.
Pilon, Mary. "Forging Path to Starting Line for Younger Disabled Athletes." The New York Times 15 Jan 2013 : (online) http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/16/sports/disabled-athletes-suit-up-raising-questions-of-logistics-and-fairness.html?_r=0
Pilon, Mary. "Forging Path to Starting Line for Younger Disabled Athletes." The New York Times 15 Jan 2013 : (online) http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/16/sports/disabled-athletes-suit-up-raising-questions-of-logistics-and-fairness.html?_r=0
i am have very strong feelings on this topic because i know a lot of people in the special olympics. i thing that for disabilities that put you in a wheel chair should not compete in the same races or sports (with the exeptions like wheel chair races and boating). because in the case of the fastest sprinter with the stilts. that could put him at an advantage. and for the sake of the athlets that are at a dis advantage then it might help to be in the special olympics as oposed to the regular olympics
ReplyDeleteI agree completely. People should not be discriminated against because of their disabilities, it's very unfair. Their life is already hard, so why do we want to make it harder? I'm not into sports myself, but I can imagine that a disabled person would want to play sports and prove to themselves that they are still good at something... And if they are being discriminated against, then they're not going to get that fulfillment. Great writing, as usual :)
ReplyDeleteNice topic, too!
I read this comment and just couldn't resist responding because sports are one of the most important things in my life. Even if I were disabled I would find some way to prove to myself that I can still play tennis, softball, and run. I have really strong feelings on this topic and you're completely right--if i were discriminated against, it would be awful because I wouldn't be able to prove to myself that I'm still worth something.
DeleteI agree with you and find it unfair that some people will tell disabled athletes that they have an advanage and others will discriminate against them. Except I also agree with Oliver--that it depends. Sometimes they are an advantage but other times disabled athletes just can't compete with ables athletes so they're put at a disadvantage. I still think discriminating against disabled athletes is unfair though.
ReplyDeleteNice post!